Coins like this have sort of gotten me off to a bad start this quarter. Last quarter I was about 66 percent accuracy and this quarter I’ve only graded about 220 coins but it’s currently only at 63 percent. Started at 69-70 for the first 30 coins or so

Weak strike def a big player, esp being New Orleans Mint

I would’ve probably guessed 55, definitely wouldn’t have guessed 58. sometimes it seems like the rarer dates get a little more leeway, I’ve seen a 1893 S Morgan with the design details a little better than I’d think for ag-3 no rim left on the obverse totally worn into the rim and on the reverse 3/4 of the coin was worn into the rim and it was ngc G4 and cac stickered

Many O mints had a known weak strike but agreed, still looks lower than 58

Also a bad strike. I checked, not CAC so I cant add insult to injury.