Guest- Welcome
- Recent Posts
- COLLECTING
- MyCollect Sets
- My Inventory
- My Wantlist NEW!
- MyCollect Catalog
- MyCollect Market NEW!
- Guess the Grade
- VERIFY
- TheftCheck
- Report Stolen
- EXPLORE
- Pages
- Groups
- Articles
- Shows & Events
- ADVERTISE
- MyCollect Ads
Recent Updates
- I've just acquired this 1889-S Morgan Silver Dollar PCGS MS-64 (CAC Green).I've just acquired this [coin:6ccb1c7a-dbb2-11f1-80ef-0660ea78a99b].0 Comments 0 Shares 98 ViewsPlease log in to like, share and comment!Commenting is disabled.
- I've just acquired this 1901 Morgan Silver Dollar CACG AU-53.I've just acquired this [coin:bf4dd996-d73f-11f1-bd0e-0660ea78a99b].0 Comments 0 Shares 101 Views
- I've just acquired this 1890-S Morgan Silver Dollar CACG MS-63+.I've just acquired this [coin:7760bdae-d17e-11f1-bffa-0660ea78a99b].1 Comments 0 Shares 189 ViewsCommenting is disabled.
-
- Part One: PCGS to CACG Crossover
So my PCGS set was in the 54 range when I retired it. I did it for many reasons which in another part I will outline. If you do not have a strong constitution, don't do this. As you will see in my posts... My collection is 98 coins, I have the rev 79 and 78 of the 7/8 7tf.
This post will deal with just the raw numbers.
98 Coins...
19 coins with + grade designation and a CAC sticker
24 Coins CAC sticker straight grade
55 Coins were not stickered
The good:
The only coins I got to use for my new set are the 24 that had already been stickered. They crossover with NO issues.
The bad:
What I did know going in was that the plus grades were not guaranteed even with a sticker. But they do consider them, there are crossed over plus grades coins out there. However, I feel that 0-12 is very unlikely. But it is something you should keep in mind within your own set. The good news is many of these are higher end bridge coins and they have been good movers. I have taken the money in difference by going lower, I upgraded many key dates. So, I didn't bother to send the other 7.
The ugly:
I pulled 10-15 coins that I felt would not cross over at all. Just by what I have learned over the last few years. Out of the remaining 40.. I sent 12 ish.. some plus grades, and some hard grades. All coins that were worthy of the grade, IMHO. Well guess what...none of them crossed. So I did not bother to send anymore. Some of these previously did not sticker, as I sent them in about a year or two ago.
What can be extrapolated from this? I have theories and heard rumors on certain things. I will leave them at the door.. although it is hard to discount them. I considered pulling the good ones and submitting them raw. But I am not looking to punish myself any further and there are still guys building PCGS registries so it benefits those guys because some were higher value coins. So that is the numbers of the swap. It is my belief based on experience, that the percentage of plus grades that cross is extremely low, and the same on straight grades that are not CAC stickered. Also, if you fail on a sticker, it is very likely you will fail on a cross. Which calls into question, if CAC is only stickering the top 10%, as I have heard, what’s the deal on the other 90% that are supposedly the grade number but not “good” enough to sticker, they should still cross right? It is my opinion because of my experience that they aren’t crossing many near misses from sticker attempts.
Sorry for the length of the post... but this is not a post of I heard this or I heard that.. this is what happened to me...
I have 32 more coins to get back to the full set. I know that CACG has very limited populations, so I am buying NGC/PCGS with CAC stickers. I am not buying OGH holders though because they are collected. I did downgrade one coin, as shown, which dropped a full grade, but the value is close to the same.
Part One: PCGS to CACG Crossover So my PCGS set was in the 54 range when I retired it. I did it for many reasons which in another part I will outline. If you do not have a strong constitution, don't do this. As you will see in my posts... My collection is 98 coins, I have the rev 79 and 78 of the 7/8 7tf. This post will deal with just the raw numbers. 98 Coins... 19 coins with + grade designation and a CAC sticker 24 Coins CAC sticker straight grade 55 Coins were not stickered The good: The only coins I got to use for my new set are the 24 that had already been stickered. They crossover with NO issues. The bad: What I did know going in was that the plus grades were not guaranteed even with a sticker. But they do consider them, there are crossed over plus grades coins out there. However, I feel that 0-12 is very unlikely. But it is something you should keep in mind within your own set. The good news is many of these are higher end bridge coins and they have been good movers. I have taken the money in difference by going lower, I upgraded many key dates. So, I didn't bother to send the other 7. The ugly: I pulled 10-15 coins that I felt would not cross over at all. Just by what I have learned over the last few years. Out of the remaining 40.. I sent 12 ish.. some plus grades, and some hard grades. All coins that were worthy of the grade, IMHO. Well guess what...none of them crossed. So I did not bother to send anymore. Some of these previously did not sticker, as I sent them in about a year or two ago. What can be extrapolated from this? I have theories and heard rumors on certain things. I will leave them at the door.. although it is hard to discount them. I considered pulling the good ones and submitting them raw. But I am not looking to punish myself any further and there are still guys building PCGS registries so it benefits those guys because some were higher value coins. So that is the numbers of the swap. It is my belief based on experience, that the percentage of plus grades that cross is extremely low, and the same on straight grades that are not CAC stickered. Also, if you fail on a sticker, it is very likely you will fail on a cross. Which calls into question, if CAC is only stickering the top 10%, as I have heard, what’s the deal on the other 90% that are supposedly the grade number but not “good” enough to sticker, they should still cross right? It is my opinion because of my experience that they aren’t crossing many near misses from sticker attempts. Sorry for the length of the post... but this is not a post of I heard this or I heard that.. this is what happened to me... I have 32 more coins to get back to the full set. I know that CACG has very limited populations, so I am buying NGC/PCGS with CAC stickers. I am not buying OGH holders though because they are collected. I did downgrade one coin, as shown, which dropped a full grade, but the value is close to the same.3 Comments 0 Shares 427 ViewsCommenting is disabled.- Love the info. Doing tge same. Especially with the new NGC 10 year thing.Love the info. Doing tge same. Especially with the new NGC 10 year thing.
- 2
-
- Thanks for sharing the open and honest insights. You have an amazing collection and in my opinion you’re making it better. I too have converted much of my Morgan collection to either CAC or CACG coins. At one point I sent in 20 to CAC and not one came back with a sticker. It was frustrating but I learned from it. I now have a better eye for what coins will cross or buy coins already stickered/CACG graded. Even though it’s been challenging, I’ve enjoyed upgrading my collection. Since CACG formed, I’ve been crossing coins and this now makes up most of my collection.Thanks for sharing the open and honest insights. You have an amazing collection and in my opinion you’re making it better. I too have converted much of my Morgan collection to either CAC or CACG coins. At one point I sent in 20 to CAC and not one came back with a sticker. It was frustrating but I learned from it. I now have a better eye for what coins will cross or buy coins already stickered/CACG graded. Even though it’s been challenging, I’ve enjoyed upgrading my collection. Since CACG formed, I’ve been crossing coins and this now makes up most of my collection.
- 2
- bretsan IMHO its just easier to buy the PCGS/NGC stickered coins and send them in. CACG does not have the populations for a higher end collection. People who have purchased my + grade coins, they think that A- I am crazy, and B- CACG sucks. Like I said, if it helps a PCGS registry guy great, I take the extra money from the downgrade and put it in a better coin in another slot. Does it suck, sure because its a time think. My 92-s went from a 53 to a CAC55. 84-CC went to a 66+ cac from a 65. My 85-cc went from a 65 to a 66cac. It's just a refocus. The hard coin will be the 93-s, I would like a 45cac, but may end up at a 40 or even a 30-35.[bretsan] IMHO its just easier to buy the PCGS/NGC stickered coins and send them in. CACG does not have the populations for a higher end collection. People who have purchased my + grade coins, they think that A- I am crazy, and B- CACG sucks. Like I said, if it helps a PCGS registry guy great, I take the extra money from the downgrade and put it in a better coin in another slot. Does it suck, sure because its a time think. My 92-s went from a 53 to a CAC55. 84-CC went to a 66+ cac from a 65. My 85-cc went from a 65 to a 66cac. It's just a refocus. The hard coin will be the 93-s, I would like a 45cac, but may end up at a 40 or even a 30-35.
- 2
-
-
-
- I've just acquired this 1888-S Morgan Silver Dollar NGC MS-64 (CAC Green).I've just acquired this [coin:898aaed4-ccb7-11f1-86e4-0660ea78a99b].0 Comments 0 Shares 232 Views
- I've just acquired this 1878 7/8TF Morgan Silver Dollar Strong 7/5 VAM-40 PCGS MS-65+ (CAC Green).I've just acquired this [coin:dc9c8b8c-ca4c-11f1-9d96-0660ea78a99b].1 Comments 0 Shares 261 ViewsCommenting is disabled.
- This coin is a rare VAM 40 and this would make the second at CAC and the 65+ grade with only 1 finer.This coin is a rare VAM 40 and this would make the second at CAC and the 65+ grade with only 1 finer.
- 1
-
-
- I've just acquired this 1900-O Morgan Silver Dollar CACG MS-66.I've just acquired this [coin:db3e9f62-ca30-11f1-a9ab-0660ea78a99b].0 Comments 0 Shares 263 Views
- I've just added a set "JFVanBurenIII's Morgan Dollars Set" (Morgan Dollars with Mintmark Type Set, Circulation Strikes, 1878-1921).I've just added a set [set:7392e86e-c9db-11f1-a2d3-0660ea78a99b].0 Comments 0 Shares 222 Views
- I've just added a set "JFVanBurenIII's Morgan Dollars Set" (Morgan Dollars "The Morgan 50 Set", Circulation Strikes, 1878-1921).I've just added a set [set:55909082-c9db-11f1-aea3-0660ea78a99b].0 Comments 0 Shares 209 Views
- I've just added a set "JFVanBurenIII's San Francisco Dollars Set" (Early S Mint Morgan Dollars Short Set, Circulation strikes 1878-1882).I've just added a set [set:43508ada-c9db-11f1-88a9-0660ea78a99b].0 Comments 0 Shares 199 Views
- I've just added a set "JFVanBurenIII's Morgan Dollars Set" (Morgan Dollars Date Set, Circulation Strikes 1878-1921).I've just added a set [set:23d94f0c-c9db-11f1-aa22-0660ea78a99b].0 Comments 0 Shares 190 Views
- I've just added a set "JFVanBurenIII's Carson City Dollars Set" (Carson City Morgan Dollars, Circulation Strikes 1878-1893).I've just added a set [set:30403f72-c9da-11f1-adcf-0660ea78a99b].0 Comments 0 Shares 175 Views
- I've just acquired this 1881-CC Morgan Silver Dollar GSA Hard Pack CACG MS-66+.I've just acquired this [coin:a8f6c5fe-c9cf-11f1-b483-0660ea78a99b].0 Comments 0 Shares 166 Views
- I've just acquired this 1900-S Morgan Silver Dollar CACG MS-65.I've just acquired this [coin:3798defa-c741-11f1-a989-0660ea78a99b].4 Comments 0 Shares 448 ViewsCommenting is disabled.
- Can you imagine going to the bank (100+ years ago), asking for a withdrawal, and getting handed a coin that looked like that?Can you imagine going to the bank (100+ years ago), asking for a withdrawal, and getting handed a coin that looked like that?
- RyanG I can barely imagine going to a bank.[RyanG] I can barely imagine going to a bank.
- ToddPollock On the right coast, we enjoy going to different places and yelling at people[ToddPollock] 😂 On the right coast, we enjoy going to different places and yelling at people
-
-
-
- I've just acquired this 1888-O Morgan Silver Dollar CACG MS-63.I've just acquired this [coin:55c19074-c675-11f1-9aab-0660ea78a99b].0 Comments 0 Shares 281 Views
More Posts
© 2026 MyCollect